Showing posts with label Over-population. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Over-population. Show all posts

Tuesday, March 27, 2012

Shame on UW River Falls

Alright, yes, somewhere, somehow, people need to learn proper horse breeding techniques. Preferably at a school, where responsible, experienced adults are there to supervise. The University of Wisconsin River Falls apparently decided to start filling that role, and thus, their horse breeding program was founded!

...except they left out the "responsible" part.



This guy's name is "Rambos Smoking Hot." The name alone is nearly criminal. He was bred, along with a couple dozen other colts, at UW River Falls, broke to ride before age two, and sold at auction last year. Oh, and before they shoved him into the ring, they bred him to two mares. At two years old. He's not totally horrible looking...though his left rear leg looks very turned-out, he neck is rather short, and I think he's a bit tied in at the knee. But hey, sure, break and breed him before age two! What?!

Here's the list of two-year-olds up for sale this year. There's forty-three of them. It's unclear how many have been bred by UW River Falls and how many have been consigned, but a disproportionately large number of them are stallions.   ( Looks like I'm wrong about this one-- thanks for the correction JayGirl!)

Why is a state-sponsored school irresponsibly pumping out tons of foals every year when we have so many excess horses? Do they really need that many to teach with?

Why is UWRF breaking horses at age two or earlier, when research clearly shows that doing often results in lasting harm to the horse? A two year old horse is equivalent to a 11-13 year old human. Just because they're big enough to do some homework doesn't mean they're physically or mentally ready to start full-time work like loping into sudden turns.



Finally, why is UWRF breeding two year old stallions to mares, before the stallions have any kind of performance record, or proven ability at anything?

Oh, and here's the cherry on the cake: not only are they irresponsible breeders, they're irresponsible owners. I just got an email from a Yahoo group, about how they're selling off their old school horse(s) for cheap rather than give them a decent retirement:

"University of Wisconsin River Falls is having their annual colt sale May 5.  After the colts from the reining class are sold they will be selling some of the schoolies.  One up for sale this year is Armani.  He is a Selle Francaise I believe and is about 20 years old and was a 3rd level dressage horse before being given to UWRF.  He has been used in beginning hunter/jumper classes as well as advanced classes.  Had an injury in the pasture a few years back but has no issues because of it.  Coach for the hunter/jumper team has never had issues with him and he can handle beginners as well as intermediates and advances though does require lighter work just due to age.  He's a great boy. I've ridden him myself and seen video of some VERY bad riders on him.  Not so much as a twitch or a bat of an eye.  He's just great. They're looking for about $350-500 for him.  At least dealer price on him.  Had some unscrupulous buyers the last few years and all of us who have been around and ridden this old boy want him to go to a great home.  Thanks so much!
contact info for Armani: Kris Hiney at UWRF (715) 425-3704 or email at kristina.hiney@uwrf.edu   She can be a little slow in responding especially during spring since she's in charge of the breeding stallions and mares at the school so please be patient if you don't contact her.  If you don't hear from  her in a week try again. "

When I tried to find any more information about Armani or any of the other UWRF school horses for sale, on the school's website or anywhere else, I found nothing.

SO, not only are they dumping off old school horses that have give them years of service, they're not even bothering to advertise them well in order to find them decent homes. Armani sounds like a fabulous horse, one any dressage kid would die to have, and I found out about it via a fan of the school posting on a Yahoo email list?! Maybe, just maybe, they could concentrate on taking care of their hard-working seniors rather than pumping out more babies?! Or at least try to do even a half-assed job of promoting them when they do dump them? Armani is about 50 years old in human years-- a hell of a time to shove him into an auction ring. It's like all those guys who are laid off from their factory jobs in their 50s, replaced by Chinese or Mexican workers overseas...except more sad, because horses don't even have welfare and social security to fall back on.

Dear River Falls: you do not have, "one of the strongest equine programs in the nation," with, "the latest theories on nutrition and exercise, to breeding, raising, training and riding young horses." If you did, you wouldn't act like irresponsible bastards.

Thursday, December 8, 2011

Horse Slaughter-- Is There Another Solution?



I hate the idea of horse slaughter. 
I also can't come up with another solution.

I don't want to hash out the whole horse slaughter debate here. Most people know the main points of both sides already. If you haven't participated in at least one vicious discussion about horse slaughter, you're either new to the horse world or new to the internet. In that case, find a summary at the bottom* of this post. What I'd really like to talk about today is finding a better solution.

Few people want horses to go to slaughter. Even those that support horse slaughter usually don't want their own horses to go through that hell. But how else do you solve the problems of over-population, unwanted racehorses, and a failing horse market?

What we should be doing, of course, is The Right Thing: not over-breeding, not keeping animals we can't afford, and taking responsibility for our senior and injured horses by paying for peaceful euthanasia instead of trying to make a little cash at the auction. I have yelled and ranted and raved about this all over the internet. Doing The Right Thing, however, is something you can't make people do.

 So what kind of programs could we create to cut back the need for horse slaughter?

In the 80s and 90s, a huge movement took hold in America: the "Spay or Neuter Your Pet" movement. Thousands of clever, heart-wrenching and funny advertisements for spaying and neuring pets were broadcast via every media imageinable, by humane societies, vets and other do-gooders. The movement coincided with awareness of human over-population, environmental problems, lab animal testing concerns and government willingness to fund social programs.


Click to enlarge.

The results were fantastic. The number of animals euthanized in pounds across America dropped dramatically. There was less neglect. Vet clinics and the government chipped in to set up low-cost spay and neuter programs for those that had too little money or too many animals. To this day, in many places in the USA you can't have an un-neutered dog without getting some weird looks and curious (or nasty) comments. It's actually rather taboo to admit to breeding a litter or two of puppies. The cat and dogs populations are still larger than they should be, and 3-4 million dogs and cats are still euthanized yearly; but things are much better than they used to be..

Why wouldn't this work for horses?

At least, that had been my first thought.

Gelding: removing balls, adding brains.


There are several reasons why this solution is problematic:
  • you can't "spay" a mare without significant cost and risk; it's not as easy as spaying a cat
  • there would be less support for such a campaign, since there are fewer horse lovers, fewer horse vets, and not enough government support
  • low cost gelding clinics can only work if you can get a whole bunch of stallions in one place at one time-- otherwise it's not cost-efficient enough for a vet to want to do it. And that's hard.
    • safety risk
    • every horse would have to have a Coggins test and rabies vaccine first (cost, risk)
    • not everyone has a trailer
    • not every horse loads well
It doesn't mean that low-cost gelding clinics can't happen. They can, and have, successfully. Look here. And here. California is even launching a state-wide program. Low-cost euthanasia programs have also helped. However, these obstacles do prevent the kind of success we've seen with the dog and cat population problems.

So, what do YOU think? Is there a better solution than slaughter? What is it?





*For newbies to the horse slaughter debate:

Proponents of American horse slaughter say that when domestic horse slaughter was stopped five years ago, it had a negative affect on horses across the country. Since you couldn't even get a hundred or so bucks for a slaughter-bound horse at an auction any more, the bottom fell out of the horse market, devaluing even nice horses and devastating the horse industry in general. Proponents of horse slaughter also say that a lack of domestic slaughter facilities means more horses being left to starve, and those that do go to slaughter face long, awful journeys and more horrific deaths in Mexico and Canada. Finally, horse slaughter would help revive the stagnant economy, providing jobs to many.


Anti-horse-slaughter experts say that the number of horses slaughtered hasn't dropped-- so if there are extra horses being neglected, it's due to the poor economy and increased shipping costs to Mexico and Canada. Whether that's true or not, they argue, neglect was always an issue even when American slaughter plants operated; some nasty people will just mistreat animals no matter what, and building a slaughter plant in every state in America won't change that. The real solution, they say, is to stop over-breeding horses; reducing the population will drive up demand (and thus prices) and reduce cases of neglect. Slaughtering horses is not "American," they claim; no one here wants to eat the horses we care about. It's not humane to the easily-spooked, sensitive horses, and its not safe for consumers to be eating horses contaminated with Bute, steroids, etc.

Tuesday, November 8, 2011

Where Free Horses Go

Remember that free paint mare I blogged about a few days ago? I'm still pretty angry about her owner dumping her on Craigslist-- and today I felt just a little more despair when I saw the ad below.

You see, horses given away for free don't always wind up in the hands of a kill-buyer (and then at a slaughter house).

Sometimes, they end up going home with a person like this:

(Click to enlarge)


I don't want to come across as a snob here-- but do you think that maybe, just maybe, a person who types in ALL CAPS, can't spell and doesn't have "allot of money" might not provide the best home for a horse?

Can you imagine a person like this ever paying for a vet call?

Would this person even know when it would be appropriate to call a vet, considering their knowledge of horse health problems seems to consist of "bad legs and feet?"

Maybe I'm being a little over-critical of this person. I'm sure that they have the best intentions. They even said "please." However, anyone who owns a horse knows that they cost a ton of money to keep-- and if you don't even have the cash to purchase one of the "ride able" $500 horses on the market right now, how can you even afford to pay for winter hay?


Giving your horse away for free is a bad idea.


There are, of course, exceptions to every rule, and some free horses do find good homes:

(He always looks this worried.)

This is Mr. Strut.

Mr. Strut was dumped for free on Craigslist a couple of years ago. My father brought him home. He's a registered, purebred Tennessee Walker, broke to ride and a true gentleman-- he even came with his papers.

The lady who gave him away, whom we shall call Bunny, just didn't want to take care of him anymore. Mr. Strut has arthritis, is prone to founder, and while he has excellent ground manners, he's not very cuddly or personable. Bunny was getting older and didn't want to deal with his issues.

I don't want to give you the wrong impression-- Bunny was a nice lady. Mr. Strut was in good health when he came to us, and she even sent along the last of his feed, his supplements and his vet records. She was worried enough about Mr. Strut to grill my dad a little on his future home. However, Bunny didn't bother to ask my father for vet references, or visit our farm. Bunny just led Mr. Strut into dad's trailer and watched them drive away. She did eventually visit-- months later.

Had we been unscrupulous people, we could have sold Mr. Strut to a horse dealer or kill-buyer that same day for at least $100-- a nice profit for the easy work of one local trailer trip. Bunny would never have wanted that, but as well-intentioned as she was, she didn't make sure we weren't "bad guys" either.

The fact that we are, in fact, "good guys" doesn't excuse her.

Good guys like us are hard to find, at least when it comes to finding a home for a free horse. We really do understand the true cost of keeping a horse, and so we're not usually eager to take on another one-- especially one with special needs. We're also pretty scrupulous about making sure our horses get handled, so we don't take on more than we have time for-- and for most of us working folks, two is about the maximum. We good guys are careful-- and so good guys are rarely the ones who want a free horse.

Even those of us that don't mind taking on special needs horses are pretty much at capacity-- because of years of the bad economy and terrible horse market, we've already got most of the unwanted horses we are capable of supporting.

Mr. Strut won the horse lottery. He's now pretty much retired, acting as a buddy for Annie and (when he's sound) an occasional trail mount for up to a whole mile of riding. He's getting downright spoiled. But so many other horses don't win the lottery. They end up with nasty people, or well-intentioned idiots with no experience and no money for feed, or in the hands of a horse dealer or kill-buyer.

Giving your horse away for free is a bad idea.

- Selling your horse would ensure a better home-- at least your know that the new owner has some money to spend on a horse's care. 
- Euthanasia might be better, especially for older horses or horses with medical conditions.  
- Surrendering to a horse rescue is a better idea-- if you can find one that has room. 

If you have no other option than to give your horse away for free, ask for references, visit the new home, Google the new owner's name, check their criminal history, make SURE the horse is going home with "good guys."